For lecturers, the pressure and repetitive nature of marking can often be draining and time consuming, and for students, doing the same kinds of written assessments for every module can be similarly exhausting. How can educators design unique assessments to try and mitigate both problems, as well as allow students to demonstrate their knowledge in more creative ways?
Jacqueline Sanchez Taylor in the department of Sociology is pioneering the concept of using zines as an assessment method in her module, Contemporary Debates in Sex Work.
Zines are non-commercial magazines, often handmade or printed in small batches, about very specific, often niche subject matter. They have historically been ways for those in marginalised or isolated groups to share culture and interests; therefore, the format fits well with the module’s themes. Many sex-worker led organisations and feminist groups have also historically produced zines to share the experiences of those who often aren’t given a voice, or to galvanise social movements.
Jacqueline asks students to create zines on a topic of their choice relating to the subject matter of sex work. Students have explored topics like the unique experiences of Black sex workers, how the negative stigma of the profession affects workers in their day to day lives and the push to decriminalise it.
Before using zines, Jacqueline used to ask students to produce posters, or PowerPoint presentations. The students responded well to the visual nature of the assessment, and the freedom to choose topics which allowed them to express their own creativity. Moving to zines gave them even more creative freedom, and the longer-form style also allowed them to explore these topics in much more depth.
"To create a high-quality, successful zine, students have to really understand the subject matter and the main topics of debate," says Jaqueline. "A lot of my students are visual learners, or are neurodiverse, so they really enjoy the opportunity to do something different."
Indeed, students have responded very positively to the zine assessment, and to the module as a whole. In the post-module survey, 84% of the students said that they were proud of their final zine, and 94% said that they found it fun to work on. Several students also said that creating the zine pushed them to develop their critical thinking skills, and to think about the topic more practically, not just in an academic sense.
This assessment format, well-received though it has been, is not without its challenges. The students are given time in scheduled lessons to work on the project, and students are encouraged both to attend the seminars and to collaborate with each other, sharing ideas and getting feedback. But if students don’t attend the seminars, then they miss out on this valuable resource.
The number of students taking the module has also increased over the past few years, making it harder for Jacqueline to give every student individualised feedback on their work in class. She is working hard to make sure that everyone continues to have the same opportunity to participate in the module, and benefit from this unique form of assessment.